Unexpected, Unique — and Made Me Think

November 4, 2009

For several reasons, it was with great anticipation that I started reading Holli Castillo’s “Gumbo Justice.” Not recently, but years back, I visited New Orleans and still have fond memories of historic homes, Lake Pontchartrain, the French Quarter, and Loyola University—all seen with the bright-eyed naiveté of youth. And memories of wonderful food!

I met Holli at the 2009 PSWA Conference, and for me, meeting an author also adds something “special” to reading their work. And on a more mundane level, my marvelous Aunt Mary makes “killer-gumbo” — a fact not relevant to Holli’s Novel, but a tidbit that definitely added title appeal (Do a lot of thinking and decision making with my stomach).

Given that mind set, “Gumbo Justice” was not at all what I expected. Part police procedural, part murder mystery, and part inter-family relationship drama, this novel also takes on legal and justice concerns—while keeping the reader involved, interested, and entertained.

I usually prefer murders that occur “off camera,” the dialogue refined, and my heroes urbane armchair detectives who only occasionally get their suits mussed. Nonetheless, the quite unique and audacious Ryan Murphy immediately yanked me into her New Orleans life, family, and ADA profession from the first paragraphs, and then continued to keep me caring about her—rough language and overt sexuality notwithstanding.

Holli skillfully transports you from your favorite reading chair into the heart of one aspect of the New Orleans criminal scene. You can feel and smell the heat, the humidity, and see the decay in the St. Thomas Housing Development. Through Ryan’s senses you read the street names, see the neighborhood, feel the pain. Ryan’s New Orleans is not the city of travelogues or my youth, but a real living city of today. And Ryan Murphy is a heroine I not only ended up liking, but also found myself rooting for every step of her journey.

And for mystery fans like me, the murder mystery in “Gumbo Justice” unfolds wonderfully, and is well worth the suspenseful wait!


2 Responses to “Unexpected, Unique — and Made Me Think”

  1. I’ve never been to New Orleans; it’s on my wish list. I’m sure it made it that much better when you read GUMBO JUSTICE. You’ve done a wonderful job reviewing Holli’s book, it sounds intriguing. The combination of procedural, mystery, and inter-family relationship drama sounds right up my alley!
    Thanks, Madeline!
    Congratulations to Holli on such a well-written book!

  2. W.S. Gager said

    Great review! I’ve read the book and you captured it wonderfully.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s